Pisqa’ 6658H:120-121;JN1:198. 1. Until when [did sacrifice at cultic sites continue]? “For you have yet to reach the refuge and the inheritance (Dt.12:9)— permission to use the cultic sites was granted from the time of taking refuge in the Land till the time of receiving the inheritance of the Land.
Now, refuge refers to the cultic site at Shiloh, while inheritance refers to Jerusalem as it is stated: “This [i.e., “Zion”] is my refuge forever” (Ps.132:14): words of R. Shimon. R. Judah says: matters must be just the opposite, [for refuge clearly refers to Jerusalem, while, inheritance refers to Shiloh]!59//T. Zev.13:20. The toseftan parallel offers a smoother reading of the dispute between R. Judah and R. Shimon over the epithets applicable to Shilo and Jerusalem:
What is represented by “refuge?” This is Shiloh.
And “inheritance?” This is Jerusalem,
As it is said: (Dt.12:9) . . :
Words of R. Judah
R.. Shimon says:
“Inheritance”—this is Shiloh;
“refuge”—this is Jerusalem,
As it is said: (Ps.132;14).
Compare Pisqa’ 1.28 on the epithet, “refuge” applied to Jerusalem. See also H:423, n.2 (66).
(דברים יב ט) עַד מָתַי? כִּי לֹא בָאתֶם עַד עָתָּה וְגוֹ׳, לִתֵּן הֶתֵּר בַּבָּמָה בֵּין מְנוּחָה לְנַחֲלָה.
Pisqa’ 6658H:120-121;JN1:198.
1. Until when
[did sacrifice at cultic sites continue]?
“For you have yet to reach the refuge and the inheritance (Dt.12:9)—
permission to use the cultic sites was granted
from the time of taking refuge in the Land
till the time of receiving the inheritance of the Land.
נַחֲלָה זוֹ שִׁילֹה, ״מְנוּחָה״ זוֹ יְרוּשָׁלִַם, שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר (תהלים קלב יד): ״זֹאת מְנוּחָתִי עֲדֵי עַד״. דִּבְרֵי רַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן. רַבִּי יְהוּדָה אוֹמֵר: חִלּוּף הֵם הַדְּבָרִים.
Now, refuge refers to the cultic site at Shiloh,
while inheritance refers to Jerusalem
as it is stated:
“This [i.e., “Zion”] is my refuge forever” (Ps.132:14):
words of R. Shimon.
R. Judah says:
matters must be just the opposite,
[for refuge clearly refers to Jerusalem,
while, inheritance refers to Shiloh]!59//T. Zev.13:20. The toseftan parallel offers a smoother reading of the dispute between R. Judah and R. Shimon over the epithets applicable to Shilo and Jerusalem:
What is represented by “refuge?” This is Shiloh.
And “inheritance?” This is Jerusalem,
As it is said: (Dt.12:9) . . :
Words of R. Judah
R.. Shimon says:
“Inheritance”—this is Shiloh;
“refuge”—this is Jerusalem,
As it is said: (Ps.132;14).
Compare Pisqa’ 1.28 on the epithet, “refuge” applied to Jerusalem. See also H:423, n.2 (66).